Conditions in Go and their weirdness
What do you think, are performance equivalents of these two options for checking conditions inside a cycle?
It all started with a “warm-up for the brain”; I had to give an example of an optimal search for an array of integers [-x .... x] of the largest even number. I wondered how much better the performance would be, if to find out an even number or not, use logical multiplication by 1.
My Go programming experience is not very big, a little more than a year and a half, I used it, though often, but purely for utilitarian purposes (well, maybe except for one project related to a high-loaded http service), so I started exactly with it. Open GoLand and write a simple test.
')
We get the result, which shows that the greater the threshold, the more often there are fluctuations in terms of performance.
It is clear that in this case, for different thresholds we have different sets of test data, the processor load (on my i5-2540M laptop) varies in the region of 20..30%, the memory occupied by the application launched from under GoLand on average about 813MB is also affects the reliability of the result, you need to implement the preservation of test sets on the disk and run all the tests for each threshold isolated from each other.
So, thinking about how to implement all this with minimal cost, I automatically correct the condition check.
on
I run the tests again ... and stop understanding anything :)
The time spent on execution begins to differ not by percents / fractions of a percent, but by 10..15%. I quickly finish 2 more tests:
A clear explanation of why the Go compiler does not optimize the code and always checks the second condition, even if the first one is false - I did not find it. Or maybe I just had an eye "zamililsya" and I do not see some obvious error? Or do I need to specify some special instructions to the compiler? I would be happy sensible comments.
PS: Yes, for interest, drove similar tests for Java 5 and Java 7/8 - everything is clear, the execution time is the same.
if a > b && c*2 > d { .... } // if a <= b { continue; } if c*2 > d { .... } It all started with a “warm-up for the brain”; I had to give an example of an optimal search for an array of integers [-x .... x] of the largest even number. I wondered how much better the performance would be, if to find out an even number or not, use logical multiplication by 1.
// 0 value & 1 == 0 //vs value % 2 == 0 My Go programming experience is not very big, a little more than a year and a half, I used it, though often, but purely for utilitarian purposes (well, maybe except for one project related to a high-loaded http service), so I started exactly with it. Open GoLand and write a simple test.
')
package main import ( "fmt" "log" "math" "math/rand" "time" ) const size = 100000000 //math.MaxInt32*2 type Result struct { Name string Duration time.Duration Value int32 } func main() { log.Println("initial array capacity: " + fmt.Sprint(size)) var maxValue int32 // // . , // // , for maxValue = 128; maxValue < math.MaxInt32/2+1; maxValue = maxValue * 2 { test(maxValue) } } func test(maxValue int32) { log.Println("max threshold: " + fmt.Sprint(maxValue)) arr := make([]int32, size) for i := range arr { arr[i] = rand.Int31n(maxValue) // sign := rand.Intn(2) if sign == 1 { arr[i] = -arr[i] } } // " " result := maxEvenDividing("maxEvenDividing", arr) log.Printf(result.Name+"\t result: "+fmt.Sprint(result.Value)+"\t\tduration %s", result.Duration) // "" result = maxEvenConjunction("maxEvenConjunction", arr) log.Printf(result.Name+"\t result: "+fmt.Sprint(result.Value)+"\t\tduration %s", result.Duration) } func maxEvenDividing(name string, arr []int32) Result { start := time.Now() var current int32 = math.MinInt32 for _, value := range arr { if value > current && value%2 == 0 { current = value } } duration := time.Since(start) result := Result{name, duration, current} return result } func maxEvenConjunction(name string, arr []int32) Result { start := time.Now() var current int32 = math.MinInt32 for _, value := range arr { if value > current && value&1 == 0 { current = value } } duration := time.Since(start) result := Result{name, duration, current} return result } We get the result, which shows that the greater the threshold, the more often there are fluctuations in terms of performance.
Compare
max threshold: 128
maxEvenDividing result: 126 duration 116.0067ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 126 duration 116.0066ms
max threshold: 16384
maxEvenDividing result: 16382 duration 115.0066ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 16382 duration 111.0064ms
......
max threshold: 8388608
maxEvenDividing result: 8388606 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 8388606 duration 109.0062ms
max threshold: 16777216
maxEvenDividing result: 16777214 duration 108.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 16777214 duration 109.0062ms
max threshold: 33554432
maxEvenDividing result: 33554430 duration 114.0066ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 33554430 duration 110.0063ms
max threshold: 67108864
maxEvenDividing result: 67108860 duration 111.0064ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 67108860 duration 109.0062ms
max threshold: 134217728
maxEvenDividing result: 134217726 duration 108.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 134217726 duration 109.0063ms
max threshold: 268435456
maxEvenDividing result: 268435446 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 268435446 duration 110.0063ms
It is clear that in this case, for different thresholds we have different sets of test data, the processor load (on my i5-2540M laptop) varies in the region of 20..30%, the memory occupied by the application launched from under GoLand on average about 813MB is also affects the reliability of the result, you need to implement the preservation of test sets on the disk and run all the tests for each threshold isolated from each other.
So, thinking about how to implement all this with minimal cost, I automatically correct the condition check.
if value > current && value&1 == 0 { current = value } on
if value <= current { continue; } if value&1 == 0 { current = value } I run the tests again ... and stop understanding anything :)
The time spent on execution begins to differ not by percents / fractions of a percent, but by 10..15%. I quickly finish 2 more tests:
func maxEvenDividing2(name string, arr []int32) Result { start := time.Now() var current int32 = math.MinInt32 for _, value := range arr { if value <= current { continue } if value%2 == 0 { current = value } } duration := time.Since(start) result := Result{name, duration, current} return result } func maxEvenConjunction2(name string, arr []int32) Result { start := time.Now() var current int32 = math.MinInt32 for _, value := range arr { if value <= current { continue } if value&1 == 0 { current = value } } duration := time.Since(start) result := Result{name, duration, current} return result } I launch and get this picture:
initial array capacity: 100000000
max threshold: 128
maxEvenDividing result: 126 duration 116.0066ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 126 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 126 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 126 duration 83.0048ms
max threshold: 256
maxEvenDividing result: 254 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 254 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 254 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 254 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 512
maxEvenDividing result: 510 duration 114.0066ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 510 duration 80.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 510 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 510 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 1024
maxEvenDividing result: 1022 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 1022 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 1022 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 1022 duration 81.0047ms
max threshold: 2048
maxEvenDividing result: 2046 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 2046 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 2046 duration 113.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 2046 duration 81.0046ms
max threshold: 4096
maxEvenDividing result: 4094 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 4094 duration 80.0046ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 4094 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 4094 duration 78.0045ms
max threshold: 8192
maxEvenDividing result: 8190 duration 107.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 8190 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 8190 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 8190 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 16384
maxEvenDividing result: 16382 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 16382 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 16382 duration 108.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 16382 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 32768
maxEvenDividing result: 32766 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 32766 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 32766 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 32766 duration 78.0045ms
max threshold: 65536
maxEvenDividing result: 65534 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 65534 duration 75.0043ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 65534 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 65534 duration 79.0045ms
max threshold: 131072
maxEvenDividing result: 131070 duration 108.0061ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 131070 duration 76.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 131070 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 131070 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 262144
maxEvenDividing result: 262142 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 262142 duration 76.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 262142 duration 107.0061ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 262142 duration 78.0044ms
max threshold: 524288
maxEvenDividing result: 524286 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 524286 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 524286 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 524286 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 1048576
maxEvenDividing result: 1048574 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 1048574 duration 80.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 1048574 duration 114.0066ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 1048574 duration 78.0044ms
max threshold: 2097152
maxEvenDividing result: 2097150 duration 111.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 2097150 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 2097150 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 2097150 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 4194304
maxEvenDividing result: 4194302 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 4194302 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 4194302 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 4194302 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 8388608
maxEvenDividing result: 8388606 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 8388606 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 8388606 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 8388606 duration 78.0045ms
max threshold: 16777216
maxEvenDividing result: 16777214 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 16777214 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 16777214 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 16777214 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 33554432
maxEvenDividing result: 33554430 duration 113.0065ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 33554430 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 33554430 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 33554430 duration 80.0045ms
max threshold: 67108864
maxEvenDividing result: 67108860 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 67108860 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 67108860 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 67108860 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 134217728
maxEvenDividing result: 134217726 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 134217726 duration 78.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 134217726 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 134217726 duration 81.0047ms
max threshold: 268435456
maxEvenDividing result: 268435446 duration 111.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 268435446 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 268435446 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 268435446 duration 79.0045ms
max threshold: 536870912
maxEvenDividing result: 536870910 duration 107.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 536870910 duration 76.0043ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 536870910 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 536870910 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 128
maxEvenDividing result: 126 duration 116.0066ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 126 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 126 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 126 duration 83.0048ms
max threshold: 256
maxEvenDividing result: 254 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 254 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 254 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 254 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 512
maxEvenDividing result: 510 duration 114.0066ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 510 duration 80.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 510 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 510 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 1024
maxEvenDividing result: 1022 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 1022 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 1022 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 1022 duration 81.0047ms
max threshold: 2048
maxEvenDividing result: 2046 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 2046 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 2046 duration 113.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 2046 duration 81.0046ms
max threshold: 4096
maxEvenDividing result: 4094 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 4094 duration 80.0046ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 4094 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 4094 duration 78.0045ms
max threshold: 8192
maxEvenDividing result: 8190 duration 107.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 8190 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 8190 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 8190 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 16384
maxEvenDividing result: 16382 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 16382 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 16382 duration 108.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 16382 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 32768
maxEvenDividing result: 32766 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 32766 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 32766 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 32766 duration 78.0045ms
max threshold: 65536
maxEvenDividing result: 65534 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 65534 duration 75.0043ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 65534 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 65534 duration 79.0045ms
max threshold: 131072
maxEvenDividing result: 131070 duration 108.0061ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 131070 duration 76.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 131070 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 131070 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 262144
maxEvenDividing result: 262142 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 262142 duration 76.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 262142 duration 107.0061ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 262142 duration 78.0044ms
max threshold: 524288
maxEvenDividing result: 524286 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 524286 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 524286 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 524286 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 1048576
maxEvenDividing result: 1048574 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 1048574 duration 80.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 1048574 duration 114.0066ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 1048574 duration 78.0044ms
max threshold: 2097152
maxEvenDividing result: 2097150 duration 111.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 2097150 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 2097150 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 2097150 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 4194304
maxEvenDividing result: 4194302 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 4194302 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 4194302 duration 111.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 4194302 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 8388608
maxEvenDividing result: 8388606 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 8388606 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 8388606 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 8388606 duration 78.0045ms
max threshold: 16777216
maxEvenDividing result: 16777214 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 16777214 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 16777214 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 16777214 duration 77.0044ms
max threshold: 33554432
maxEvenDividing result: 33554430 duration 113.0065ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 33554430 duration 78.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 33554430 duration 110.0063ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 33554430 duration 80.0045ms
max threshold: 67108864
maxEvenDividing result: 67108860 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 67108860 duration 77.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 67108860 duration 112.0064ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 67108860 duration 80.0046ms
max threshold: 134217728
maxEvenDividing result: 134217726 duration 109.0063ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 134217726 duration 78.0044ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 134217726 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 134217726 duration 81.0047ms
max threshold: 268435456
maxEvenDividing result: 268435446 duration 111.0064ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 268435446 duration 79.0045ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 268435446 duration 114.0065ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 268435446 duration 79.0045ms
max threshold: 536870912
maxEvenDividing result: 536870910 duration 107.0062ms
maxEvenDividing2 result: 536870910 duration 76.0043ms
maxEvenConjunction result: 536870910 duration 109.0062ms
maxEvenConjunction2 result: 536870910 duration 80.0046ms
A clear explanation of why the Go compiler does not optimize the code and always checks the second condition, even if the first one is false - I did not find it. Or maybe I just had an eye "zamililsya" and I do not see some obvious error? Or do I need to specify some special instructions to the compiler? I would be happy sensible comments.
PS: Yes, for interest, drove similar tests for Java 5 and Java 7/8 - everything is clear, the execution time is the same.
Source: https://habr.com/ru/post/444182/
All Articles