What is bad?

Scarce son came to his father,
And asked Kroha
What is good,
And what is bad
V. Mayakovsky

Recently, I drew attention to the frequent reduction of karma or to the labeling of a comment as “bad”, just because your opinion is opposite to the opinion of another person. Is it not time to clearly define why you can put a minus?

Yes, I began to stumble upon a lack of understanding of people. Like giving arguments, everything seems OK, arguing with each other. Not until the first blood, and so, little by little. But for some reason all this is manifested in exposing cons in karma and in comments. But, sorry for what? For the fact that my opinion is critical in some matters? For the fact that I do not want to be silent, but to say that I actively support the idea of ​​Habr? This is not quite clear to me. If there are arguments that are not refuted in the same comments, does anyone have the right to put a minus?

The same goes for pluses. It is not always clear how they are displayed. I noticed that often the plus gets the first post, and the one that supports the idea of ​​the post. And if the post does not correspond to the opinion of the person because of the minuses, is it necessary to submit to it?
')
Next, look at the name of the plus and minus for comments on Habré. This is a “bad” and “good” comment. Perhaps someone else at school said that the words “bad” and “good” do not correspond to an adult. He has arguments, and these words are too vague to give a precise definition of a post.

I suggest that you still clearly define by what parameters you can put plus and minus, raise and underestimate karma. Otherwise, the situation with phrases like “it is a pity that I can’t give a boost” will never end.

Offhand, I recall the appearance of a set of mobile etiquette rules for one cellular operator. Is it time to start your own habraetiket, which will clearly spelled out what you can put a minus, and what not, how to behave and what you should not write at all.

Attention
According to the results of the discussion of the topic, a small set of rules of habraetiket was drawn up We invite you to discuss!