How not to write on Habr: Antireyting 2017

Discussing the results of the analysis of articles for 2017 , we concluded that not only the best publications were interesting for us and other habrovans , but it would also be interesting to know which articles and comments were worse. Today we publish anti-rating of publications and comments on Habrahabr in 2017. This is done because you can learn a lot from someone else’s negative experience, leave these mistakes in the outgoing one and not repeat them in the new year. This post does not carry other purposes, please treat this with understanding.

Top 30 publications with the lowest rating

1. A brief reaction to the material about Xored - Rating -103
2. It's time to kill C # - Rating -78
3. The TOR network in Russia is fully controlled by the FSB - Rating -57
4. Preparing git reset correctly - Rating -51
5. Cj - a new programming language - Rating -47
6. And once again on the legality of the control of employees - Rating -47
7. How to choose the right laptop for programming - Rating -42
8. Non-traditional orientation of the BEP - Rating -40
9. I received a letter, or was the admin of the state site linked to the malware distribution ... - Rating -40
10. Another ex-employee sued Forbes 4 million rubles for unlawful dismissal - -40
11. Uneducated youth. Whats left behind the scenes - Rating -39
12. Making a free SSL certificate in 2017 - Rating -38
13. Login form with sending an encrypted password - Rating -38
14. Let's live together - Rating -35
15. Riot of idlers, or again about the accounting of working time - Rating -34
16. Bonus vs depremiation - Rating -33
17. SALI is your ~ programming language - Rating -31
18. MUK becomes distributor of Oracle - Rating -30
19. Welcome Habrozhiteley - Rating -28
20. Alive Script - a programming language for children 12+ - Rating -27
21. The golden ratio (Phi number) and time, your opinion? - Rating -27
22. How to become a programmer - Rating -26
23. New class for MySql: writing queries to the database is now quick, easy and convenient - Rating -24
24. Turning off the PC anywhere in the world (JAVA) - Rating -24
25. More than java? - Rating -24
26. Java examples from books and documentation - Rating -24
27. Parsim on Java - Rating -23
28. What is needed for high-quality Web development? - Rating -22
29. Microservice Architecture - motive shift on target - Rating -22
30. Bitcoin - feet with clay feet - Rating -21
')
Each article has its own reason for the low rating and most likely it is pretty obvious to readers, however, if you need an explanation, you can easily find it in the comments under each article. Usually a comment with a high rating reflects the general or most popular opinion of habrovchan. There is an opposite of this phenomenon: the situation when a comment in the opinion of the community shows the incompetence or inadequacy of the author, contains an unfair demand, judgment or insult, is simply an example of a bad sense of humor. Better to tell based on the facts.

Top 30+ comments with the lowest rating

The site rules are written

Usually, IT specialists and those interested in this field are cultural people who respect not only themselves, but also their interlocutors and readers. In order for the resource to remain a platform for communication of such people, there are rules for violation of which moderators can lower the account rights to ReadOnly.

Here is a list of what should not be done on the resource ...

More often than not, situations from this list are the cause of a sharply negative overall comment rating.

The manifestations of incompetence or erroneous judgments from the point of view of the community are the first type that best describes the response comment of the user Error1024



1. habrahabr.ru/post/318876/#comment_9998678 - Rating -42
2. habrahabr.ru/company/pvs-studio/blog/330394/#comment_10252710 - Rating -44
3. habrahabr.ru/post/331144/#comment_10270298 - Rating -39

Sometimes a dispute begins, forming a whole group of comments-leaders of anti-rating
4,5,6.
habrahabr.ru/post/343168/#comment_10537952 - Rating -65
habrahabr.ru/post/343168/#comment_10538028 - Rating -76
habrahabr.ru/post/343168/#comment_10538060 - Rating -60

7.8 - “Experience in the development world is worthless. Nothing at all, there is no correlation between experience and skill. And it is important to understand "
habrahabr.ru/post/336838/#comment_10391956 - Rating -47
habrahabr.ru/post/336838/#comment_10392108 - Rating -41

9,10.
habrahabr.ru/post/332296/#comment_10296774 - Rating -40
habrahabr.ru/post/332296/#comment_10296702 - Rating -36

11. habrahabr.ru/post/320734/#comment_10041590 - Rating -39

12. habrahabr.ru/post/333008/#comment_10311434 - Rating -58

13. habrahabr.ru/post/319332/#comment_10007180 - Rating -52

Usually, if the manager makes the wrong decision, it means that the programmer could not bring the full brunt of the consequences. Typically, programmers have low social skills, so you need a special person to convey to the authorities thoughts about the technical component of the project.

14. Comments about “prano-studies” and esoterics habrahabr.ru/company/smartprogress/blog/323710/#comment_10113250 - Rating -36

15. and 16. Unsuccessful humor
habrahabr.ru/post/332816/#comment_10306538 -73
habrahabr.ru/company/yandex/blog/333522/#comment_10317052 -52

Type 2 - political

From the rules of the site

it does not follow...
Initiate political discussions and participate in them.
The theme of our resource is defined quite clearly. For reasoning about politics there are much more suitable sites. But not "Habr".

17, 18 - Contradiction with the spirit of free software and an attempt to politicize the development and distribution of software
habrahabr.ru/post/337290/#comment_10402092 - Rating -59
habrahabr.ru/post/337290/#comment_10402630 - Rating -37

19,20,21,22.
habrahabr.ru/company/fbk/blog/335778/#comment_10364480 - Rating -56
habrahabr.ru/company/fbk/blog/335778/#comment_10364800 - Rating -41
habrahabr.ru/company/fbk/blog/335778/#comment_10364498 - Rating -48
habrahabr.ru/company/fbk/blog/335778/#comment_10364502 - Rating -54

In 2017, there were quite loud publications that covered the author’s problem situation related to the second side, which, due to the readers ’evaluation, became an anti-hero. In cases where representatives or defenders of the "anti-hero" expressed their point of view in the comments, new participants appeared in anti-rating.

23,24,25,26. Comments Department of Information Technology on the publication [UPDATED + Comments] At first they steal, and when you win, they kill you
habrahabr.ru/post/335010/#comment_10348564 - Rating -91
habrahabr.ru/post/335010/#comment_10348562 - Rating -44
habrahabr.ru/post/335010/#comment_10348810 - Rating -61
habrahabr.ru/post/335010/#comment_10349258 - Rating -36
and
27. habrahabr.ru/post/335688/#comment_10363734 - Rating -46

28.29 - Xored
habrahabr.ru/post/336092/#comment_10374894 - Rating -35
habrahabr.ru/post/336092/#comment_10375130 - Rating -40

3 type - insult

From the rules of the site

it does not follow...
Insult other users, do not follow the emotions
Math, insults, personal transitions, euphemisms, trolling are good ways to quickly and reliably change the current account status to ReadOnly.

As output

From the rules of the site

The list of violations remains open, because you can always think of something not described above. In such cases, the moderators (more generally, the users of the website note. Aut. ) Are guided by common sense and their own sense of beauty. It is not worth discussing their decisions and creating propaganda publications on this topic - if they banned someone, it means they had a pretty good reason.

As you can see, there is nothing complicated in the rules, and we will be grateful if you follow them.

PS According to the link in our vk group , you can download an Excel file with basic data about the publications that we have collected for this analysis.