Criticism
Articles and comments to them, questions and detailed answers, blogs, magazines ... Everywhere we write something or lay out work in order to get some kind of assessment. Criticism, praise, or just the answer.
One cannot argue with this, and whoever is asked, everyone will answer in unison - I am for sound criticism , of course . Is it so? Can people really perceive it adequately?
All people want their opinion to be accepted, they want to agree with them (otherwise, what is the sense to put forward their position?). Such is the human psychology - the desire to dominate.
And if the first commentary on their work is - your work is real shit , they will erase it. Especially if the author is young, and this is his first work. Experienced authors, and also, if a good hundred comments are left, will be asked to comment on why it is crap, or they will simply be ignored. And it is right. Logically, damn it.
But as soon as I registered my account on Vkontakte (I confess, Vkontakte is evil, but I'm not going to sit there), rummage through friends lists of my classmates and acquaintances, leave a couple of comments on topics like “ How do you like a picture / avatar ” or just polls such as " How do you feel about love / cats / spoons / legs ..." (there are 10 records in all) in a rather critical style, but with sensible justifications - how they were instantly erased. Almost everything. Naturally, the comments “ Avatar super. Cem-tsem .
In conclusion - an example with artlebedev.ru and his Business Lynch. 95% percent of the "sculpted" think something like this: 1. He said my job is crap. He is just a snicker designer, he was really lazy to look and appreciate. My work is awesome.
2. He said that my work is good (hee, rarely, but still). What, I myself do not know that my work is super?
3. He pointed out my mistakes. He is too nagging, which means that my work is super.
And only 5% (statistics from the ceiling, but look before and after (in the case of sites) and everything will become clear) will take into account the errors and correct them. And these 5% are professionals. Maybe already those, maybe - in the future.
')
Change the mentality of the country is unrealistic. Especially since ours. For comparison, deviantart.com - here you will not find a comment in the daytime with fire in the style of “ Your photo sucks ” or even simply “ Your pic is not very good ”. They do not criticize at all - either well or nothing (they are all already dead, yes? =).
Why is everyone so afraid of her, this terrible criticism? Why do not want to hear the bitter truth? ..
Everything is difficult to cover, and the topic will be cumbersome, I will write in the sequel. Good luck! We are for sensible criticism =)
One cannot argue with this, and whoever is asked, everyone will answer in unison - I am for sound criticism , of course . Is it so? Can people really perceive it adequately?
All people want their opinion to be accepted, they want to agree with them (otherwise, what is the sense to put forward their position?). Such is the human psychology - the desire to dominate.
And if the first commentary on their work is - your work is real shit , they will erase it. Especially if the author is young, and this is his first work. Experienced authors, and also, if a good hundred comments are left, will be asked to comment on why it is crap, or they will simply be ignored. And it is right. Logically, damn it.
But as soon as I registered my account on Vkontakte (I confess, Vkontakte is evil, but I'm not going to sit there), rummage through friends lists of my classmates and acquaintances, leave a couple of comments on topics like “ How do you like a picture / avatar ” or just polls such as " How do you feel about love / cats / spoons / legs ..." (there are 10 records in all) in a rather critical style, but with sensible justifications - how they were instantly erased. Almost everything. Naturally, the comments “ Avatar super. Cem-tsem .
In conclusion - an example with artlebedev.ru and his Business Lynch. 95% percent of the "sculpted" think something like this: 1. He said my job is crap. He is just a snicker designer, he was really lazy to look and appreciate. My work is awesome.
2. He said that my work is good (hee, rarely, but still). What, I myself do not know that my work is super?
3. He pointed out my mistakes. He is too nagging, which means that my work is super.
And only 5% (statistics from the ceiling, but look before and after (in the case of sites) and everything will become clear) will take into account the errors and correct them. And these 5% are professionals. Maybe already those, maybe - in the future.
')
Change the mentality of the country is unrealistic. Especially since ours. For comparison, deviantart.com - here you will not find a comment in the daytime with fire in the style of “ Your photo sucks ” or even simply “ Your pic is not very good ”. They do not criticize at all - either well or nothing (they are all already dead, yes? =).
Why is everyone so afraid of her, this terrible criticism? Why do not want to hear the bitter truth? ..
Everything is difficult to cover, and the topic will be cumbersome, I will write in the sequel. Good luck! We are for sensible criticism =)
Source: https://habr.com/ru/post/27358/
All Articles