Open rating. Which CMS is most suitable?

The task is to implement the thematic catalog of user-rated articles with the possibility of collective editing.

What options were considered:

1. Wiki . The first thing that comes to mind with the words "collective editing". Disadvantages: there is no explicit ranking (there is a polling module that didn’t want to work, and user rights with respect to this module are not very clear)
2. Social engine (the same Livestreet, for example). Clear and proven rating mechanism. Disadvantages: binding at the time of publication (when the thing hangs in the catalog untimely)
3. Rating engine (type RatingEngine for Plone). Also clear rating mechanism. Disadvantages: the catalog part seems to have to be done by hand. Plus, the system is less clear than alternatives.

Maybe in other popular CMS (Drupal, Joomla) there are modules for solving this problem?